Being from Northeastern Pa... We never made Squirrel Pot Pie. First off it should have crust on top of it if it's pie...
However always like to take a couple squirrel and roast them in a roaster right along with vegtables.. Carrots, potatoes, mushrooms, cabbage, onions...Yep roasted squirrel ain't half bad surrounded by vegtables in a roasting pan and popped into the oven...!!!!!!